In Assassin’s Creed Valhalla, players eventually reach a moment where they must uncover a traitor among their allies. This pivotal quest, commonly referred to as the Who to Accuse segment, not only tests your investigative skills but also plays a significant role in shaping the story’s outcome. The choice is more than a simple selection; it’s about reading subtle clues, evaluating characters’ motives, and making a decision that impacts your journey through the Viking world. Making the wrong accusation can alter the dynamic of future events, leading to mistrust, tension, or even unintended consequences for Eivor and their clan.
The Traitor Accusation Quest
This part of the game unfolds during the Grantebridgescire arc, where Eivor helps Soma reclaim her territory from occupying forces. Once the enemies are pushed out, the celebration is short-lived Soma reveals there is a traitor among her inner circle. The player must then choose who to accuse between her three trusted advisors: Birna, Lif, and Galinn. Each of them has unique personalities and possible motivations, which can make the choice challenging.
Understanding the Stakes
The quest titled An Unwelcome Guest asks players to weigh their choices carefully. Choosing the wrong person will not only damage relationships but also cause the true traitor to escape justice. If you choose correctly, you will strengthen your alliance with Soma and gain a valuable companion down the road.
Investigating the Suspects
Before making your accusation, Eivor must investigate clues and gather testimonies from each suspect. Exploring their backgrounds, behavior, and dialogue will provide important insight. Let’s break down each potential traitor and the evidence tied to them.
Birna
Birna is a fierce warrior who has fought loyally beside Soma. She’s straightforward, confident, and appears to have genuine affection for her leader. During your investigation, you’ll find that she has no obvious reason to betray Soma. Her frustration stems more from not being fully trusted than from any ambition or resentment.
Lif
Lif is the group’s builder and engineer. He is practical, quiet, and focused on logistics. One of the key clues that make him suspicious is that a tunnel leading into the city was used by the enemy, and Lif was the one who constructed that tunnel. However, he claims it had been sealed off and implies someone else must have reopened it.
Galinn
Galinn stands out due to his erratic behavior and obsession with visions and destiny. He believes he is chosen by the gods and often speaks in cryptic, unsettling tones. He has expressed distrust of Soma’s leadership and seems the most disconnected from the group. His erratic actions make him a key suspect.
Clues That Point to the Traitor
While all three characters have potential motives, there are clear indicators pointing toward one in particular. Investigating the village and listening to the locals reveal these clues:
- The tunnel was reopened recently suggesting internal sabotage.
- Paint used to mark escape routes was found near the water, where the betrayer escaped.
- The sabotage happened during an assault when trust was critical.
Piecing together the dialogue, locations, and inconsistencies, players can make an informed decision about who to accuse. While Lif’s tunnel is a tempting lead, and Birna has her emotional moments, the most consistent clues point toward Galinn as the traitor.
Who to Accuse: The Correct Choice
Based on the evidence, the correct person to accuse inAssassin’s Creed ValhallaisGalinn. His motivations, erratic nature, and distrust of Soma align with the behavior of a betrayer. He believes his actions were guided by prophecy and makes no true effort to hide his madness.
Consequences of Accusing Galinn
If you accuse Galinn:
- Soma acknowledges your decision and supports you.
- Galinn confesses and is executed for his betrayal.
- Birna survives and is grateful, later becoming a potential Jomsviking in your crew.
- The alliance with Soma remains strong and unshaken.
This path ensures the best outcome for the clan’s stability and for your relationship with Soma. Additionally, you gain a loyal companion who can aid in future battles, which is a valuable long-term benefit.
What Happens If You Accuse the Wrong Person
Accusing either Lif or Birna leads to negative consequences. Soma may question your judgment, the real traitor (Galinn) remains free, and your alliance becomes strained. Additionally, you lose the opportunity to recruit Birna, and trust within your leadership circle suffers.
If You Accuse Lif
- Lif is executed despite his innocence.
- Galinn survives, still harboring his dangerous beliefs.
- Birna and Soma react negatively to the execution.
If You Accuse Birna
- Birna is killed, and Soma feels betrayed by your choice.
- Lif and Galinn remain, and the traitor is left unpunished.
- You lose Birna as a recruitable ally forever.
In either incorrect path, the morale and strength of your alliance take a significant hit, and it diminishes the strategic depth of your future options in the game.
Tips for Making the Right Choice
To ensure you accuse the correct traitor in Valhalla, follow these tips during your investigation:
- Explore every dialogue option with the three suspects.
- Visit the crime scene and look for physical clues like the paint and tunnel.
- Pay attention to behavior patterns Galinn’s words reveal his instability.
- Cross-check testimonies to find contradictions.
- Trust your logic more than your gut the evidence builds a clear case.
Why This Choice Matters for Storytelling
This quest highlights the evolving nature of storytelling in Assassin’s Creed Valhalla. Unlike earlier entries where choices had limited consequences, Valhalla emphasizes weighty decisions that ripple throughout the game. By making a logical accusation, players see how actions reflect leadership, strategy, and emotional intelligence. It brings depth to Eivor’s journey and personalizes the Viking saga further.
Character Development Through Investigation
Choosing who to accuse is not just about eliminating a threat it’s about showing what kind of leader Eivor is becoming. The process strengthens your understanding of loyalty, judgment, and the blurred lines between honor and survival.
The Who to Accuse moment inAssassin’s Creed Valhallaserves as one of the game’s most immersive narrative decisions. By examining evidence and observing character behavior, players can correctly identify Galinn as the traitor and maintain harmony within Soma’s alliance. This quest underscores the importance of critical thinking in a world defined by war, loyalty, and hidden agendas. Choosing wisely here rewards not only gameplay success but also a more fulfilling story experience that reflects the complexity of Viking life and leadership.