St. Augustine, Florida, is a charming city known for its rich history and beautiful coastal scenery. Along with its historic sites, St. Augustine boasts a vibrant culinary scene featuring a variety of nice restaurants that cater to diverse tastes. Whether you’re seeking fine dining, casual eats, or fresh seafood, the city offers numerous options that blend excellent flavors with inviting atmospheres. Many of these restaurants take pride in sourcing local ingredients and crafting menus that reflect both the cultural heritage and coastal bounty of the region, making dining in St. Augustine a memorable experience for residents and visitors alike.
Historic District Dining
One of the best places to enjoy nice restaurants in St. Augustine is within the Historic District. Here, the ambiance is enhanced by cobblestone streets and centuries-old architecture, creating a unique backdrop for meals. Many establishments in this area specialize in offering dishes that combine traditional Southern flavors with modern culinary twists.
- Columbia Restaurant: Established in 1905, this iconic Spanish-Cuban restaurant is a staple in St. Augustine. Known for its paella, fresh seafood, and classic Cuban sandwiches, it’s a must-visit for those who want authentic flavors served in an elegant setting.
- Preserved Restaurant: Featuring Southern-inspired cuisine with a focus on locally sourced ingredients, Preserved offers a menu that changes seasonally. The ambiance reflects the charm of the old city with a cozy, inviting interior.
- Michael’s Seafood Restaurant: For lovers of fresh seafood, Michael’s is a popular choice. It combines quality ingredients with excellent service, offering dishes such as fresh oysters, shrimp scampi, and blackened fish specialties.
Coastal and Seafood Specialties
Given St. Augustine’s coastal location, seafood plays a prominent role in many nice restaurants around the city. The availability of fresh catches from the Atlantic Ocean ensures that diners enjoy vibrant, fresh flavors that highlight the essence of coastal cuisine.
- Saltwater Cowboys: This lively restaurant blends coastal cuisine with a casual atmosphere. Known for its creative seafood dishes and cocktails, it offers favorites like shrimp and grits and crab cakes, all made with fresh local ingredients.
- O’Steen’s Restaurant: Famous for its fried shrimp and other seafood classics, O’Steen’s has been a local favorite for decades. It offers a straightforward menu focusing on quality and flavor, making it a go-to spot for authentic Southern seafood.
- Catch 27: Combining sustainable seafood practices with innovative recipes, Catch 27 serves dishes such as seared scallops and grouper, crafted with a dedication to freshness and presentation.
Fine Dining Experiences
For those seeking an upscale night out, St. Augustine offers several fine dining establishments that blend refined menus with elegant decor and exceptional service. These restaurants often feature chef-driven dishes, extensive wine lists, and thoughtfully curated dining experiences.
- Raintree Restaurant: Located in a historic house, Raintree offers a sophisticated menu featuring steaks, seafood, and gourmet appetizers. The garden courtyard provides a romantic setting perfect for special occasions.
- Casa Benedetto: This Italian restaurant is renowned for its authentic recipes and high-quality ingredients. From handmade pastas to fresh seafood, Casa Benedetto delivers a rich Italian dining experience.
- The Floridian: Known for its Southern-inspired modern cuisine, The Floridian emphasizes locally sourced ingredients and innovative flavor combinations, making it a standout on the St. Augustine fine dining scene.
Casual and Family-Friendly Options
Not all nice restaurants in St. Augustine require formal attire or reservations. The city also offers many casual dining spots that are perfect for families and laid-back gatherings. These places often serve hearty portions and feature menus that appeal to a wide range of palates.
- Pizza Time: A beloved local pizzeria offering classic and specialty pizzas, salads, and sandwiches. Pizza Time is popular for its friendly service and relaxed atmosphere.
- Preserved Provisions: A casual café offering sandwiches, salads, and daily specials made from fresh, local ingredients. It’s a great spot for brunch or lunch in a cozy setting.
- Sunset Grille: Located near the water, this family-friendly restaurant serves seafood and American dishes with beautiful views. It’s a popular choice for casual dinners with a scenic backdrop.
Unique and Eclectic Dining
St. Augustine’s culinary landscape also includes several unique and eclectic restaurants that offer creative menus and vibrant atmospheres. These establishments often incorporate global influences or focus on artisanal preparations.
- Cellar 6: Known for its extensive wine selection and tapas-style small plates, Cellar 6 is a favorite for those who enjoy sharing diverse flavors in an intimate setting.
- Maple Street Biscuit Company: This Southern-inspired eatery specializes in biscuit sandwiches with a variety of fillings, perfect for breakfast or lunch.
- The Kookaburra: An Australian café that offers excellent coffee, breakfast items, and unique treats like Vegemite toast, bringing an international flair to St. Augustine.
Outdoor and Waterfront Dining
Taking advantage of the city’s natural beauty, many nice restaurants offer outdoor seating or waterfront views. Dining al fresco while enjoying the fresh sea breeze adds to the overall experience, especially during pleasant weather.
- Salt Life Food Shack: Offering a relaxed coastal vibe, Salt Life Food Shack has outdoor patios where guests can enjoy fresh seafood and tropical cocktails with a view.
- Riverside Grill: Situated along the scenic San Sebastian River, this grill features a menu full of fresh seafood, steaks, and burgers. The outdoor seating area is perfect for enjoying sunsets.
- Beachcomber Restaurant: Located near the beach, Beachcomber offers fresh seafood and casual American fare with open-air dining that captures the essence of coastal living.
Tips for Dining in St. Augustine
When visiting nice restaurants in St. Augustine, it’s a good idea to make reservations in advance, especially during peak tourist seasons. Many popular spots fill up quickly, so planning ahead ensures a smoother experience. Additionally, exploring the local specialties and seasonal dishes enhances the enjoyment of the city’s culinary offerings. Whether you prefer seafood, Southern cuisine, Italian flavors, or eclectic menus, St. Augustine’s diverse restaurant scene has something for everyone.
St. Augustine offers a wealth of nice restaurants that provide not only delicious food but also memorable dining experiences. From historic district charm and fine dining to casual family eateries and waterfront views, the city caters to a wide array of tastes and occasions. Whether you are a visitor eager to sample local flavors or a resident looking for a new favorite spot, St. Augustine’s restaurant scene promises quality, variety, and warm hospitality. Exploring these dining options is a delightful way to complement the city’s rich cultural and historical attractions.